Total average


Helpfulness ( 73.3 )
Clarity ( 73.7 )
Easiness ( 96.3 )
Approachability ( 90.3 )
Organisation ( 67.3 )
Availability ( 69 )

Reviews (3)

Dr Charmine Hartel 97.5

Professor Charmine is a guru in Human Resources Management and it was a great honor to take MGTS7612 this wonderful course with her. Her stimulating lectures and brilliantly taught materials has broaden my understanding of designing and staffing subject. The interesting case studies that professor Charmine had shed lights on throughout the semester were very interesting. Further, the class discussions make me love this course to the most as it increases my enthusiasm and motivation.

In addition, what I love of Professor Charmine is her amazing teaching style of MGTS7612 that she hasn't focus solely on theories and models but rather on challenging the norms, by finding the current and real staffing issues in existing actual companies and suggesting ways to overcome them, which what we’re going to face on the real life after graduation, she is making our life easy by straightforward to the point techniques.

MGTS7612 course materials were very well developed and included everything that was needed. The lecture slides were also well organized and the lectures were very clearly presented. It was great that I had this very positive experiences with professor Charmine. I hope that I can guarantee more than one subject with Professor Charmine again throughout my journey at UQ.

Which course did you take? (e.g. MGTS1301)


  • Exceptional course lecturer and unique teaching experiences
  • The lectures were very interesting and make me eager to listen
  • The lecturer makes Networking of interesting case studies and topics. She makes the class lively
Negatives No negative points
Posted on July 4, 2018 1:08 pm
Kwan Ho CHAN
Dr Charmine Hartel 100.0

Explanation in the course was clearly delivered, essentially all the subjects being taught are well delivered and received by the students. Extremely outstanding easiness and helpfulness found in the lecturer throughout the course of this semester, overall it was a positive and great journey in this exploration of the HR topics.

Which course did you take? (e.g. MGTS1301)


  • Friendliness
  • Very knowledgeable on the topics
Negatives No negative points
Posted on June 19, 2018 2:57 pm
Dr Charmine Hartel 37.5

Charmaine is a really nice person but jeez she is so disorganised. I took MGTS3604 in Sem 1, 2015 and she would go off on a tangent for an hour, realise she had only 15 minutes left before the lecture finished then skip over like 60-80% of the lecture slides saying 'oh read that in your own time' or 'read that later on by yourself'. I realise after the first few weeks that there was no reason to even attend the lectures as she just talked and talked and talked about random and pointless things - using the lecture recording was an easy way to fast forward over her banter and get to the actual lecture content.

She also has a habit of citing her own references from journal articles she found - most of the lecture slides having more than 3-4 slides of references at the end that she'd cited arbitrary. When I asked her if the referencing of outside sources was examinable she said 'Whatever I feel is important, I will test you guys on, that may be what I've referenced or may just be the textbook, not sure yet, it depends...'. So frustrating.

Lecture slides were not uploaded until literally a few hours before the lecture (it was at 8am Fridays so I never got a chance to print it out beforehand as I had to leave). Lecture slides were confusing, filled with ridiculous amounts of external referencing and no help on identifying key theories to study for and she just skipped over everything anyway.

Overall, I honestly wouldn't take any other courses run by her. It's just too frustrating trying to chase her down and ask her questions about assessment that should already be answered in the ECP, like the formatting for the essay we did, what the word limit was and what the structuring was for the assessment... None of that was explained to us.

Which course did you take? (e.g. MGTS1301)


  • Nice person
  • Knowledgable on HR topic
  • Extremely disorganised
  • Lecture slides were almost impossible to decipher, ridiculous amounts of external referencing used and no help on identifying key theories to study for
  • Goes off on tangents every lecture
Posted on June 14, 2015 10:25 pm

Submit your own review

Please make sure to read our Review Guidelines before posting a review.